All guides

Waterfall enrichment, explained: why one data provider is never enough

October 24, 20262 min read

Every B2B data provider has holes. One has strong coverage of US tech companies, another of European SMBs, a third of people who changed jobs last month. Ask only one of them for a work email and you get its coverage, and nothing more.

A waterfall asks several providers in a fixed order and stops at the first good answer. If the first provider has the record, the rest are never called. If it does not, the next one gets a turn. The result is the combined coverage of every provider in the chain, paid for one answer at a time.

Why the order matters

Each step only runs for the rows the previous steps missed. So the first provider sees every row, the second sees the misses of the first, and so on. That makes the first slot the most expensive one to get wrong: put your cheapest provider with good coverage there, and save specialist or expensive sources for the end of the chain.

The arithmetic is simple enough to do before you run anything. If the first provider finds 72% of emails and the second finds 64% of the rest, two steps cover 1 − 0.28 × 0.36 ≈ 90% of rows. A third provider at 62% takes it to about 96%. That is the calculation Kiln shows before every run, using each provider's declared hit rate.

What "found" should mean

A provider can return an address it guessed from a name pattern. If that guess fails verification, you have paid for an email that bounces. The waterfall should treat an unverified guess as a miss and move on, and you should not be billed for it.

This is where tools differ most in practice. Ask any vendor: do you charge for an address that fails verification? For a catch-all domain? For a repeat lookup you already paid for last week?

The three settings that decide the bill

  1. Provider order. Cheapest high-coverage source first. Re-check the order every quarter, because coverage drifts.
  2. Stop rule. Stop at the first verified answer, never at the first answer.
  3. Cache. A lookup you ran last month should be free the second time. Emails decay slowly enough that a 30-day cache is safe.

What it costs

On Kiln, one verified work email through Hunter costs 3 credits, about 3.7¢ at the Growth plan's credit price. Misses, errors, failed verifications and cached repeats cost nothing. You can run the same chain on your own provider keys, in which case the vendor bills you directly and Kiln charges a small orchestration fee.

Kiln's email waterfall can use Hunter, Apollo, Icypeas, Prospeo, Findymail, Anymail Finder, Dropcontact. You can try a full waterfall on sample data in the demo sandbox, no account needed.

More guides